Saturday, May 15, 2004

City asked to regulate rent-to-own


Critics say deals tilted in favor of seller/landlord

By Kevin Aldridge
The Cincinnati Enquirer

DOWNTOWN - A state lawmaker and a coalition of city neighborhoods want Cincinnati City Council to adopt a policy regulating the common real-estate practice of offering rent-to-own homes in poor and working-class communities.

SPECIAL REPORT
Home schemes, broken dreams, The Enquirer's special report on 'flipping' and foreclosures.
Rep. Steve Driehaus, D-Cincinnati, says too many people are getting ripped off on "lease-option" deals that cost unwary buyers thousands of dollars. Driehaus and residents from East Price Hill to Camp Washington have drafted a proposed ordinance for tougher enforcement of existing landlord-tenant laws to curb abuses.

The group will present the proposal on the steps of City Hall Monday morning.

"It really is a scourge on the neighborhoods and it tends to hurt low- and moderate-income families who are trying to actually save up enough money to buy a home," Driehaus said. "These guys are taking advantage of those dreams and putting people in pretty bad situations."

Lease-option contracts often require a renter to buy a home after paying an up-front option fee of at least $1,000 and making rent payments for about two years. If the renter meets all terms and conditions, he has a chance to get a loan and buy the house.

Some investor groups say lease-options are ideal for renters who want to buy a house but have poor credit history and lack down-payment money.

But Driehaus, a resident of Price Hill, said his main complaint is that some contracts require renters to perform all maintenance on a home - a tactic used by landlords to shift large repair bills to the renter.

The proposed ordinance states that in Cincinnati, lease-option agreements would be subject to all the state's landlord-tenant laws. It says that the agreements must contain the words "This is not a contract to buy" and that landlords must fully disclose the condition of the property to renters.

The measure further states that a lease-option agreement cannot be valid until an independent third-party home inspection is conducted. It also calls for a clearly defined sale price to be agreed upon before the agreement can be executed. The landlord must pay for the recording and filing of the lease-option agreement with the county recorder within 30 days of its execution.

"This isn't trying to force the hand of council," Driehaus said. "I've talked to quite a few council members and they are very supportive."

Driehaus said he wants to include language about lease-option agreements in a bill already being considered in the statehouse concerning predatory lending.

In November, Driehaus asked Ohio's attorney general to rule on whether offering rent-to-own homes is permitted under state law. His request was denied.

Email kaldridge@enquirer.com




TOP STORIES
Attendance builds despite wet start
Take our trash, towns say, but don't disturb our sleep
Downtown safe despite killing, police say
EPA calls Fernald plan illegal
Items left behind by ancients found

REVIEWS
Jammin' rocks Central Parkway
Pops, singing cop arouse emotions
'Orphans' depicts a life on the fringe
'Hansel' overcomes hip conceit

IN THE TRISTATE
Degree from Art Academy opens door to European study, travel
Park swimsuits: Keep it clean, and no metal
Walnut Hills troupe puts on a believable 'Picnic'
GOP compares Kerry to cicadas
Clifton plans move forward
Health coverage juggled in game
Woman tests heart device
City asked to regulate rent-to-own
Five charged in fatal shooting
News briefs
Neighborhood briefs
Ex-public defender avoids arrest
Cleveland suburb ends practice of allowing use of substitute jurors
Ohio Democrats pick Springer as delegate
Ohio court blasted for soliciting flight
Public Safety briefs
Tire pile going down slowly

ENQUIRER COLUMNISTS
Jesus scholar speaking at Knox Church
Good Things Happening

LIVES REMEMBERED
G. Edmondson lived 15 years with new heart
Robert McKenna of F&M Group proud Elder grad

KENTUCKY STORIES
Builder submits revised plan
Latonia's classic car show shut down
Covington race narrows soon
State projecting surplus this year
State approves treatment plant