Wednesday, May 19, 2004

Bingo bill disagreements unlikely to be settled before summer recess



By Leo Shane III
Gannett Columbus Bureau

COLUMBUS - Senate Republicans don't expect to pass new charitable gaming laws by the end of the month, despite cries from Democrats and social organizations that such inaction could cripple veterans posts and fraternal clubs.

Senate President Doug White, R-Manchester, said he is hopeful that an agreement can be reached, but said he would not support the gaming revisions without major changes.

Other Republicans went even further, saying the proposal has significant flaws that very likely can't be fixed within the next week.

"If I were a betting man, I'd bet this won't happen until November," said Sen. Jay Hottinger, R-Newark, the No. 3 ranking Republican in the Senate. "Something will pass this session, but it won't be before the summer."

Both the House and Senate are expected to recess from June until November.

Supporters of the bingo bill say waiting five more months for new legislation will force many financially struggling clubs to close.

About 500 club members rallied at the Statehouse on Tuesday, lobbying senators to act quickly to help save their organizations.

Expense restrictions key

The legislation is the third major rewrite of Ohio's charitable gaming laws in three years. House members overwhelmingly passed the legislation in March.

The major point of contention deals with expenses. Current law mandates 55 percent of all gaming profits go directly to charities, while the remainder can be used for select costs associated with operating a club or tavern.

Tim Young, spokesman for the Affiliated Clubs of Ohio, said those restrictions are hurting small veterans posts and fraternal organizations, which cannot pay for their operations under the current rules.

"We're trying to save the clubs in the state of Ohio," he said.

But Senate leadership said, as written, the bill would let clubs use their gambling profits for whatever they choose, which goes against the constitutional mandate that gambling profits go to charity. That could lead to a return of illegal storefront bingo parlors, which prompted the earlier gaming law revisions.

Senate Democrats on Tuesday unsuccessfully tried to force their Republican colleagues into a full vote on the Senate floor. Minority leader Greg DiDonato, D-Dennison, told supporters his members would "do whatever it takes to have this measure voted on."

Governor has concerns

Orest Holubec, spokesman for Gov. Bob Taft, said the governor has not taken a definite stance on the bill, but has expressed concerns over the constitutionality of how gambling profits can be used.

White, who is an American Legion member, said he isn't worried about the prospect of debating the bill throughout the summer and passing it late in the year.

"As it stands now, I cannot support this," he said. "I'd rather do something right than do it quick."




TOP STORIES
Summer air traffic to soar
Arts center hires veteran director
More police hitting streets
Tall Stacks owed big payment

KY. PRIMARY RESULTS
It'll be Davis vs. Clooney
Bunning, Mongiardo easily win U.S. Senate primaries
Three Covington City Council incumbents move forward
Twelve to vie for six Independence City Council seats
Roeding fights off challenge in 11th Senate District
Nurse wins 1st race for office
Keene wins in 67th District Democratic upset

IN THE TRISTATE
Bingo bill disagreements unlikely to be settled before summer recess
Former mayor a tireless civic gem
Study: 'Jury still out' on reforms
Broadnax denied erasure of record
Housing to join stores
Lakota wants resident input before acting on ballot issue
News briefs
Two mental health agencies consolidating operations
Neighborhood briefs
Panhandler law may end if not renewed today
City may streamline pit bull procedures
Church dismisses gay marriage ruling's appeal
Public safety briefs
Report suggests breaking promise on Fernald waste
Women told to ponder finances
Agency outreach questioned
Growing pains unabated

ENQUIRER COLUMNISTS
Little red wagon gets her to class
Crowley: Tough fight anticipated

LIVES REMEMBERED
Christine Davis, 96, pioneer soldier
Jane Gillespie, 68, corporate attorney, sailor

KENTUCKY STORIES
Firetrucks rush to wrong state
Gasoline may have caused sensor failures
25 hit the big one: $12.6M Lotto ticket
Ky. news briefs