Wednesday, May 19, 2004

Broadnax denied erasure of record


Judge notes crime was selling crack

By Sharon Coolidge
The Cincinnati Enquirer

[photo]
Stanley Broadnax
A judge refused Monday to erase former Cincinnati Health Commissioner Stanley Broadnax's criminal conviction on drug charges.

Broadnax, who was paroled in 1997 after serving two years in prison for selling crack cocaine, asked the court in February to expunge his criminal record.

Hamilton County Common Pleas Judge Patrick Dinkelacker denied the request during a hearing, saying Broadnax does not qualify for expungement because the six charges he was convicted of must be considered individually.

Under Ohio law, expungements are intended to give first-time offenders with a small number of convictions a second chance at a clean slate.

If a record is expunged, it is removed from public view and no longer available to potential employers or anyone else.

"This is much, much more than a mistake," Dinkelacker said. "It was a breach of trust. ... It was felonies that just can't be overlooked; and, based upon that, I feel it would be an abuse of my discretion to allow the expungement."

"Day in and day out I see what is happening in the community," Dinkelacker said. "Drug dealing is a bad situation."

At the time of his drug conviction, Broadnax had resigned as health commissioner but still had his medical license.

And if anyone can see the ill effects of dealing drugs it is a doctor, Dinkelacker said: "You take an oath to help people, not hurt people. Selling drugs certainly hurts people."

Broadnax, 57, said he would appeal Dinkelacker's decision to the 1st District Court of Appeals.

"I'm disappointed with the verdict, but I'm also inspired," said Broadnax, who now works to help people overcome drug addiction. "There are thousands of people in Hamilton County that deserve a second chance."

During the hearing, Broadnax apologized.

He explained that he has kicked his drug habit with treatment and attends Narcotics Anonymous meetings. He is involved in his church. And, he works for Ammons Workforce Development, a local church-based workforce development program.

"I'm attempting to give back to the community," he said.

But he said it's difficult for convicted felons to move on because their criminal convictions hinder them in getting a job and finding a place to live.

Because of the convictions, Broadnax said, he lost his medical license and hasn't been able to get homeowner insurance. He declined to say if he was seeking the expungement in order to get his medical license back.

In Hamilton County last year, 513 people sought to have their criminal convictions erased; 401 of which were granted.

E-mail scoolidge@enquirer.com




TOP STORIES
Summer air traffic to soar
Arts center hires veteran director
More police hitting streets
Tall Stacks owed big payment

KY. PRIMARY RESULTS
It'll be Davis vs. Clooney
Bunning, Mongiardo easily win U.S. Senate primaries
Three Covington City Council incumbents move forward
Twelve to vie for six Independence City Council seats
Roeding fights off challenge in 11th Senate District
Nurse wins 1st race for office
Keene wins in 67th District Democratic upset

IN THE TRISTATE
Bingo bill disagreements unlikely to be settled before summer recess
Former mayor a tireless civic gem
Study: 'Jury still out' on reforms
Broadnax denied erasure of record
Housing to join stores
Lakota wants resident input before acting on ballot issue
News briefs
Two mental health agencies consolidating operations
Neighborhood briefs
Panhandler law may end if not renewed today
City may streamline pit bull procedures
Church dismisses gay marriage ruling's appeal
Public safety briefs
Report suggests breaking promise on Fernald waste
Women told to ponder finances
Agency outreach questioned
Growing pains unabated

ENQUIRER COLUMNISTS
Little red wagon gets her to class
Crowley: Tough fight anticipated

LIVES REMEMBERED
Christine Davis, 96, pioneer soldier
Jane Gillespie, 68, corporate attorney, sailor

KENTUCKY STORIES
Firetrucks rush to wrong state
Gasoline may have caused sensor failures
25 hit the big one: $12.6M Lotto ticket
Ky. news briefs