Thursday, June 3, 2004

Plea averts trial


Mental illness claimed in '01 school shooting

By Jim Hannah
The Cincinnati Enquirer

COVINGTON - A Latonia woman who shot the mother of her child's classmate in a busy schoolyard in 2001 pleaded guilty earlier this week to a charge of manslaughter.

The last-minute deal ended more than two years of legal wrangling over whether Marjorie McElfresh was sane, and averted a trial that was scheduled to begin Wednesday.

Assistant Kenton Commonwealth's Attorney James Redwine will recommend a sentence of 12 years. Under state law, McElfresh would serve 85 percent of the time, or more than 10 years, before being eligible for parole.

McElfresh originally was charged with assault. A grand jury increased that to murder after the victim died nearly a year after the shooting. Tuesday, McElfresh changed her plea to "guilty but mentally ill" to first-degree manslaughter.

McElfresh told Kenton Circuit Judge Greg Bartlett that "voices" were telling her the victim, Linda Gegner, was the mastermind of an imagined plot to molest her child.

Gegner was shot one time with a .380-caliber handgun in September 2001 in front of several children and teachers at Latonia Elementary School in Covington.

Defense attorneys had argued that McElfresh had been delusional for years. Court records indicate the defense was prepared to ask a jury to acquit McElfresh by reason of insanity. Two psychiatrists and two psychologists had agreed McElfresh was insane at the time.

Prosecutors said McElfresh understood her actions. McElfresh called ahead and had school officials keep her child late, according to authorities. She then showed up with a gun and shot Gegner in the school parking lot.

E-mail jhannah@enquirer.com




TOP STORIES
Catholics try to reconcile faith and political choices
Catholics speak out on politics and religion
Pilarczyk deflects sacrament issue
Take 3: 'Cops' invited back to city
'Cops' cameras roll in Covington
Our spelling 'shuud be lojical,' protesters cry
Students inspired by war, service

IN THE TRISTATE
Drake Center request gets divided reaction
Students learn de-stress method
News briefs
Reserves head back to Iraq
Neighbors briefs
State court widens liability for abuse
Close 2 centers for disabled, panel urges
Video gambling effort likely to fail
Pleasant Ridge mobilizes
Pot bust nets 164 pounds, two arrests
Public safety briefs
Morning music comes to Lebanon
Businesses pledge help if art school will move
Fernald cleanup fails powder test
Fees would pay for growth
Recreation center still perplexes West Chester
Brother gets four-year term in fatal shooting of sister

ENQUIRER COLUMNISTS
Good Things Happening
Bronson: Storm alert: Run for it! Enstupidation
Crowley: NKU tuition hike needs a perspective

LIVES REMEMBERED
Robert Dehan led company despite illness

KENTUCKY STORIES
Homes plan clears hurdle
Kentucky news briefs
Fletcher wants suit suspended
Nine abused kids needed her, nine times she took them in
Neighbors help to buy funeral for slain man
Plea averts trial
Talks proceed on diploma equivalent for dropouts