Tuesday, June 15, 2004

Mayor wants spending at English Woods studied



By Kevin Aldridge
The Cincinnati Enquirer

ENGLISH WOODS - Cincinnati Mayor Charlie Luken Monday called for an audit of the Cincinnati Metropolitan Housing Authority to assess how it spent millions of federal dollars on repairs and improvements at English Woods.

The mayor's comments followed an hour-long tour with residents of the 948-unit public housing complex.

Luken, who was joined on the tour by council members Christopher Smitherman and Laketa Cole, said the city would also take an inventory of the services it provides to English Woods.

The mayor said the housing agency has engaged in "a war of attrition" by refusing to make renovations or effectively market the rental property.

"I question CMHA's accountability to the people of English Woods," Luken said. "They are basically doing what they were told not to do."

The housing authority wants to raze the World War II-era apartment complex, which it owns, and build single-family homes atop the prime western Cincinnati land.

Luken and City Council oppose demolition. In October, the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development rejected the demolition plan.

Since then, the housing authority has done little marketing of the property. Instead, English Woods tenants are being moved out of the area once targeted for demolition and into two additions to the complex - 118 units built four decades ago and the 138-unit Marquette Manor high-rise for the elderly and disabled.

A 6-foot chain link fence now seals off access to more than 300 unoccupied barracks-style apartments along Sutter Avenue.

"It looks like a minimum security prison," Luken said. "If you want people to act with pride, you have to treat people with respect. If you or your family lived here, how would you feel?"

Housing Authority Director Donald Troendle said renovation - estimated at about $130,000 per unit - would be too costly. Though structurally sound, Troendle said, the complex is riddled with failing heating and cooling systems, asbestos and lead-based paint.

"The housing authority is in full compliance with its program requirements and has detailed records of what funds we've spent over the years," Troendle said. "And contrary to belief, we did not receive money specifically for English Woods."

Troendle said there is a 70 percent vacancy rate among 700 units. Only 28 people have chosen to move there since January, Troendle said.

"English Woods is our housing of last resort," Troendle said.

Don Driehaus, a city-appointed member of the housing authority's board, said he would like to see the units expanded and renovated one block at a time.

"The board's inclination was to turn a blind eye and walk away, but I think we need to give it a try," Driehaus said.

Tenants of English Woods said Monday they were pleased the mayor and council are taking a more active interest in their plight.

"We need people to see what we live with and what our community is like," said Marcia Battle, a member of the English Woods Civic Association. "It is not as bad as they say it is."

---

E-mail kaldridge@enquirer.com




ENQUIRER COLUMNS
Bronson: Answerman in the know on Huggs, others
Pitchon Lev helps the poor in Israel

TOP LOCAL HEADLINES
Norwood can seize properties
Paper maze frustrating
Teens' aching heads keep on
'Verb' program works to get kids moving
Log says Huggins stop not his first
Peters new UC decision maker
Kennedy: It's Huggins' program
Ohio mall terror plot charged
Brother insists Ohio suspect hated terror
Witnesses describe killer's tortured life
Mayor wants spending at English Woods studied
Group of young people visits to do politics hip-hop style
Library nears completion of $1M computer system
Customer charged in vendor's death
Public safety notebook
Local news briefs

KENTUCKY HEADLINES
Bunning boosts local charities via autographs
Three receivers protect center
Knox Co. porn store owner will challenge obscenity law
Newport water bills to rise

EDUCATION HEADLINES
SPECIAL SECTION: Salute to scholars
Grads have steel wills
After an amazing turnaround, scholar leaves them cheering
More Tristate scholars
Proposed closings draw fire
Groups won't endorse levy if schools ignore advice
Schools proceed with new buildings
Notes: In the schools

NEIGHBORS
Web site tracks sections of city
Halt called to home building
Lakota gets compensation
Neighbors digest

LIVES REMEMBERED
Bill Hunsberger was former VP for Enquirer
Joseph Cappel served Chile as missionary