Cincinnati.Com
NKY.COM  |  ENQUIRER  |  CIN WEEKLY  |  Classifieds  |  Cars  |  Homes  |  Jobs  |  Help
Currently:
72°F
Sunny
Weather | Traffic
The Enquirer
HOME
NEWS
ENTERTAINMENT
SPORTS
REDS
BENGALS
LOCAL GUIDE
MULTIMEDIA
ARCHIVES
SEARCH
 
 TODAY'S ENQUIRER 
 Front Page 
 Local News 
 Sports 
 Business 
-- Editorials 
 Tempo 
 Home Style 
 Travel 
 Health 
 Technology 
 Weather 
 Back Issues 
 Search 
 Subscribe 

 SPORTS 
 Bearcats 
 Bengals 
 High School 
 Reds 
 Xavier 

 VIEWPOINTS 
 Jim Borgman 
 Columnists 
 Readers' views 

 ENTERTAINMENT 
 Movies 
 Dining 
 Horoscopes 
 Lottery Results 
 Local Events 
 Video Games 

 CINCINNATI.COM 
 Giveaways 
 Maps/Directions 
 Send an E-Postcard 
 Coupons 
 Visitor's Guide 

 CLASSIFIEDS 
 Jobs 
 Cars 
 Homes 
 Obituaries 
 General 
 Place an ad 

 HELP 
 Feedback 
 Subscribe 
 Search 
 Newsroom Directory 


  \
Thursday, June 17, 2004

Standardized testing's sorry history


Your voice: David Pannkuk

Standardized testing is a billion-dollar industry, and it controls the direction of American education and many businesses. How standardized tests came about makes for an interesting read.

In 1860, Francis Galton defined intelligence as mental abilities based on selected and inherited traits. Galton went on to found the Eugenics Society, which advocated a birthrate favoring superior strains or races "so that their progeny shall gradually outnumber and replace those people with lower mental abilities."

In 1875, Charles Spearman enlarged on Galton's position. "General mental ability is passed on from generation to generation and replaces the view that humans might be intelligent in several ways including creativity, perceptions, and memory." Spearman recommended using school subjects to measure intelligence.

In 1904, Albert Binet was charged by the French Ministry of Public Instruction with finding a reliable means for identifying mentally "defective" children in order to justify keeping them out of regular classrooms. Verbal/language skills dominated. Cultural and background differences were ignored.

In 1916, Lewis Terman of Stanford University developed "The Measurement of Intelligence" based on the Stanford-Binet Intelligence Test. The Terman Scale defined potential vs. actual performance or achievement. The test did not account for social or economic opportunity.

In 1923, Carl Brigham of Princeton University was assigned to make a national inventory of American mental capacity. His study used U.S. Army recruits comparing native born, recent immigrants, and black Americans. The tightly timed tests, based on the Terman scale, consisted of mental gymnastics on meaningless tasks.

In his report, A Study of American Intelligence, Brigham concluded that the inability to respond to American culture is an undesirable trait indicated by the "real differences" in the intelligence of immigrants. Brigham returned to Princeton, where he created the Scholastic Aptitude Test (SAT) and became secretary of the College Entrance Examination Board. His editor, Elwood B. Cubberly, stated that the primary function of American education is to train the majority of Americans to be competent in an industrial or production setting where intelligence is not required.

The dictionary defines intelligence as the ability to learn and/or understand how to deal with new or trying situations. And to that point, American standardized tests say what?

David Pannkuk of Columbia Township is a workplace specialist and software developer.

Want your voice here? Send your column or proposed topic, 400 words or fewer, along with a photo of yourself, to assistant editorial editor Ray Cooklis at E-mail rcooklis@enquirer.com; (513) 768-8525.




EDITORIAL PAGE HEADLINES
Terror's threat in the heartland
Chabot cuts at Alaska timber subsidy
Letters to the Editor: How did Iraq war go horribly wrong?
What you say: On Norwood ruling
Your Voice: Standardized testing's sorry history



 

Jim Borgman
Jim Borgman
Jim Borgman is The Cincinnati Enquirer's Pulitzer Prize winning editorial cartoonist.
Jim Borgman
 • Today's cartoon

 • Archive

 • Biography

 • Pulitzer Prize

 • 25th anniversary


Letters to the Editor
Use our online form to send a letter to the editor of The Cincinnati Enquirer.

Or mail to:
The Cincinnati Enquirer
Letters to the Editor
312 Elm Street
Cincinnati, OH 45202


Related Links
e the People
e.the People
is an online public forum. Think of it as the digital town hall for The Cincinnati Enquirer.


Cincinnati.Com
Search our site by keyword:  
Search also: News | Jobs | Homes | Cars | Classifieds | Obits | Coupons | Events | Dining
Movies/DVDs | Video Games | Hotels | Golf | Visitor's Guide | Maps/Directions | Yellow Pages

  CINCINNATI.COM  |  NKY.COM  |  ENQUIRER  |  CIN WEEKLY  |  Classifieds  |  Cars  |  Homes  |  Jobs  |  Help


Search | Questions/help | News tips | Letters to the editors | Subscribe
Newspaper advertising | Web advertising | Place a classified | Circulation

Copyright 1995-2007. The Cincinnati Enquirer, a Gannett Co. Inc. newspaper.
Use of this site signifies agreement to terms of service updated 12/19/2002.