Tuesday, July 27, 2004

Loveland testing of water invalid

By Sheila McLaughlin
Enquirer Staff Writer

LOVELAND - The city's use of a noncertified analyst to test its drinking water from December through May has resulted in a notice of violation from the Ohio Environmental Protection Agency.

The agency said it can't accept the city's results that the water was free from coliform bacteria because the analyst did not have proper certification. State officials are requiring the city to send out notices to water customers by mid-August, saying Loveland did not conduct the required monitoring for coliform for six months.

City officials, however, said the water is safe because it tested negative for coliform each time. No one has reported getting sick from the bacteria, which can cause serious illness in children, the elderly and people with immune disorders. Tests several times a week since May have been negative for coliform.

Assistant city manager Tom Carroll characterized the violation as a technicality, but said the city was to blame. The city has since changed testing companies.

The problem occurred when the city hired a new firm to conduct water quality testing last fall.

The chosen firm, Q Laboratories of South Fairmount, gathered the required samples weekly and tested them for coliform, but the city did not have a written contract or any agreement that the work was to be done by a certified analyst, Carroll said.

"That's our mistake. They are a certified lab with a certified technician, they just did not have that person test our water."

Heather Lauer, OEPA spokeswoman, said certification is required because it guarantees a level of competency. The agency ignores results of tests that are not performed by a certified analyst, she said.

What type of tests the city expected from Q Laboratories is a matter of dispute.

Carroll said it should have been clear that the city wanted tests that met OEPA standards because they sought out a certified firm.

Company president Dave Goins said he dealt personally with former public works superintendent Joe Geers to set up the water analysis, but was told the city did not want certified testing. The company offers both types of testing, he said.

"We told them right off the bat there was no way the EPA was going to accept this," he said.


E-mail smclaughlin@enquirer.com

Clintons promise to make Kerry next president
Clinton calls himself "foot soldier"
Text of former President Clinton's speech
Agreed on Kerry, Ohio Dems debate locals
Heinz Kerry's blunt offering: 'Shove it'
Young candidate enjoys star status
Reagan brings stem-cell debate to top
Delegates given guidance
2004 DNC Photo gallery

Fernald cleanup halted - how long is unclear
Gay-marriage opponents wary
Amber Alert successes: Children safe in Ohio, Ky.
West Nile virus kills Butler man
Cough cases not abnormal
Bengals seek $30M in lawsuit vs. county
Twice, she's faced death
Crash survivor appears in court
Bush, task force discuss 9/11 report
Franklin man arrested on child porn charges
River shutdown for lock repairs will back up barges
Local news briefs

Juvenile to face federal charges
Anti-Bush music event coming
Fifth lien filed against team
Heeeeeeeeeere's Fletcher!
Hustler sues Lexington to sell adult materials
Women's group to host forum
Rebuffed by tellers, suspect is arrested
Beer-vote man charged in threat to policeman
Ky. vies to retain police academy

Still ahead of the class
Drum & bugle corps compete

Underground wires protect rolling stock
Late bill rationale disputed
Police, fire levies on ballot
Green Township considers tax levy
Loveland testing of water invalid
Poll transportation available in Fairfield

Local grads win business award

Donna Lee Whalen, 66, chief's wife, deputy clerk