Tuesday, August 3, 2004

Heimlich says no to Drake tax


But two other commissioners support putting new levy on ballot

By Cindi Andrews
Enquirer staff writer

A Hamilton County commissioner said Monday that he won't support a tax levy of any size for the Drake Center.

"This is one of the worst examples of excessive spending and lack of accountability that I have ever seen," Phil Heimlich said in announcing his position.

Heimlich's opposition won't stop a tax vote. The other two commissioners support a levy, although they have not decided the size of the tax request.

The long-term acute-care hospital in Hartwell has requested a five-year levy that would raise $99 million, a 39 percent increase over its expiring levy. The levy subsidizes about 20 percent of Drake's budget.

Heimlich and some others, however, have said no other county supports such a hospital with a tax levy, and they have raised questions about Drake's per-patient costs.

Drake officials fired back at Heimlich.

"He continues to make exaggerations and inaccuracies about Drake," spokeswoman Kathy Graham said. For instance, while Heimlich said the hospital has nine marketing employees, Drake says it has five.

Commissioner Todd Portune, who has undergone treatment at Drake, supports a request on the Nov. 2 ballot.

"It provides a very valuable service in the county that would be difficult if not impossible to replace,'' he said. "To eliminate Drake would throw the health-care community into turmoil."

Commissioner John Dowlin likewise voiced support, saying Drake's high-quality care ultimately lowers health-care costs.

Still, it is rare that a request to put an existing levy on the ballot would not get unanimous approval from commissioners. Heimlich's opposition could hurt the levy's chances with voters, said political analyst Gene Beaupre, a professor at Xavier University.

"If I thought Phil will go silently into the night, that's one thing," Beaupre said. "But I suspect he'll be active. I think this levy is going to have a very tough time."

The commissioners have until Aug. 19 to decide whether levies may go on the county ballot. The Hamilton County Mental Retardation and Developmental Disabilities agency is also seeking a levy, which commissioners have indicated they will support.

---

E-mail candrews@enquirer.com




ENQUIRER COLUMNS
Bronson: Beauty lives beyond shore of 'real life'
OSU history major knows war stories

TOP LOCAL HEADLINES
A new station of freedom
Police board suggests discipline
Luken won't run for mayor
Wilkinson: Luken an unpredictable act, as always
Schools, cities face votes today
Heimlich says no to Drake tax
Lemmie to hire 2 for police
Dog who bit boy awaits his fate
Man faces 15 charges in crash that killed 4
Gay-marriage petitions ready
Mexico approves vaccine
From hospital to jail
Teen racer loses license
Feisty 'fat activists' mobilize, fight diet obsession
Afternoon crash kills driver, injures 3 others
Local news briefs

KENTUCKY HEADLINES
Clooney still refining views
Father berates killer of child
Newport commissioners revive shopping center plan
Sexual abuse lawsuits now include nuns

EDUCATION
CPS studies construction monitor
Score comparison easier on Education Dept.'s site
Finneytown district levy to be topic of meeting

NEIGHBORS
'Night Out' participants gang up against crime
Clifton builder outlines plan for funeral-home site

LIVES REMEMBERED
Robert Lee McDaniel III, 53, active in community
Auctioneer C. Kenneth Kenner, 77, retired from Cincinnati Bell