Wednesday, August 4, 2004

Lawsuit: Bad grades killed jobs


Bogus certification test failures cost them money

By Dan Horn
Enquirer staff writer

A Cincinnati man claimed in a lawsuit Tuesday that he and thousands of other teacher candidates lost jobs and money because they received failing grades on certification tests they actually passed.

The class-action lawsuit filed in U.S. District Court in Cincinnati is the first in the country to accuse the testing organization, Educational Testing Services, of antitrust violations as well as negligence.

Paul Perrea, a former electrical engineer turned substitute teacher, claims the New Jersey-based firm negligently designed and scored the certification tests and has failed to change policies that allowed the mistakes to occur.

Perrea's suit also accuses the nonprofit company of monopolistic behavior, claiming ETS so dominates the certification process that it is able to charge unreasonable fees.

"We believe ETS used its monopoly power and leveraged that power to make money in related services," said Perrea's lawyer, Phyllis Brown.

Educational Testing Services officials declined to comment Tuesday on the lawsuit or the antitrust claim.

"We're going to continue to work with the people involved in this and try to do what's right," said Peter Yeager, a company spokesman.

ETS acknowledged the scoring errors last month when officials revealed that more than 4,000 teacher candidates in 19 states were incorrectly graded as failing their tests. At least 1,200 of those candidates were from Ohio.

Passing scores on the tests are required for licensing as an instructor in grades 7 through 12. Most states require the tests, and Educational Testing Services produces the most widely-used exam.

Perrea, 44, said he's certain the failure to correctly score his test cost him jobs as a math or science teacher. He said it also caused embarrassment when he was told he failed the essay portion of the test.

"Teaching is one profession where grading and tests matter," Perrea said. "There's a lot of shame involved."

He later learned, however, that his failing score of 156 - short of the minimum 165 score - should have been a passing score of 174.

Perrea's lawsuit seeks a court order barring monopolistic behavior and asks for unspecified damages for the teacher candidates whose tests were incorrectly scored.

E-mail dhorn@enquirer.com




SUMMER LEVY VOTES
8 school levies fail
County election sites
'No!' Norwood majority roars about 14-mill levy
Monroe increase fails
Mt. Healthy OKs levy

TOP STORIES
Festival seating likely to return
Mayor Luken may be angling for run at statewide office
Freedom Center taps emotions
Last exhibit intended to get people talking
Young workers lack coverage

IN THE TRISTATE
Spending up at Cincinnati schools
Ex-felons' voting rights misstated
Lakota puts levy on ballot this fall
Local news briefs
Mercury lurks: Think twice about eating fish caught in Ohio streams
Lead-laden parcel won't delay planned Warren County subdivision
Neighbors briefs
Wording leaves details to courts
Columbus Zoo and Aquarium euthanizes 39-year-old gorilla with inoperable cancer
Panel to debate opening park gate
Public safety briefs
Lawsuit: Bad grades killed jobs
Too fast, two crashes, two die
Residents praise new park's trail

ENQUIRER COLUMNISTS
Grad awarded $1K scholarship

LIVES REMEMBERED
Rev. James A. Sutton, 82, was foster parent to 148
Janet M. Trigg taught nursing care for cancer

KENTUCKY STORIES
Bush bypasses Bunning on post
Woman, 72, claims sex abuse in 1930s
Silver Grove first up
Florence advised: Un-Mall
18 N.Ky. schools fall short
NRA gives endorsement to Geoff Davis
Bunning addresses business group
Louisville GOP leader faces criticism on poll watchers
Human Rights Commission has acting director
Bunning pressed on stem cells