Thursday, August 5, 2004

Reactions emotional as seating ban lifted



By Cliff Radel
Enquirer staff writer

In Cincinnati, the seemingly playful term "festival seating" will always be linked with the harsh reality of the word "tragedy."

ONLINE POLL
The connection occurred Dec. 3, 1979. That's when 11 people died in a rush for the doors before a Who concert at Riverfront Coliseum. Now known as U.S. Bank Arena,the coliseum that night offered first-come, first-served festival seating.

Considering that fateful history, it should come as no surprise that strong reactions came from City Council's Wednesday decision. Council unanimously repealed the festival seating ban established after the Who tragedy and replaced it with a new set of requirements.

Good riddance to "a bad law, a knee-jerk reaction," said Bill Donabedian. He's the president and co-founder of the MidPoint Music Festival, the annual September music showcase held downtown.

"Getting rid of the festival seating ban will have a huge cultural and economic impact on the city," Donabedian added. He predicted the new rules would spawn everything from more concerts and money spent downtown to retaining the Queen City's youth.

Mary Bowes sees things differently.

"This is going to make Cincinnati a mecca for rock bands? I don't think so," she said. "This just proves once again that money talks. City Hall is going to do what it wants and listen to what big business wants."

Bowes lives in Wyoming. She lost a son at the Who concert. Peter Bowes was 18.

"I have this little picture of Peter with a little guitar next to it," she said. "Every time I look at it, I think: 'It shouldn't have happened.'

"I hope they know what they're doing down at City Hall."

Paul Wertheimer shares that hope. After the Who tragedy, he served as chief of staff on the task force that led to Cincinnati's festival seating ban. He's the founder of Crowd Management Strategies.

Following fatal concert crushes in Rhode Island and Chicago in 2003, Wertheimer served as a consultant for officials investigating what caused the loss of a combined 121 lives.

Wertheimer also serves on the board that helped establish the Life Safety Code of the National Fire Protection Association.

Portions of that code are incorporated into Cincinnati's new festival seating ordinance.

"That has me worried," Wertheimer said.

"Festival seating can be reasonably safe - if all of the provisions of the Life Safety Code are included.

"If the city is not careful, it could be heading for chaos, injury and possibly tragedy - things Cincinnati has avoided for nearly a quarter of a century."

E-mail cradel@enquirer.com




TOP STORIES
Teens' wireless feat could be world record
Man in boat crash reaches plea deal
Festival seating unanimously OK'd

LEVY VOTES
Simmering anger hurt tax levies
Schools consider fall votes
Schools consider new tries

IN THE TRISTATE
Election official's conviction reinstated
CPS board split on overseer
Deerfield Twp. meeting breaks up
Warren sheriff defends Deerfield post
Donation helps run Fairfield activities
Reactions emotional as seating ban lifted
Local news briefs
Despite last-minute negotiations, Lowe's zoning fails in Green Twp.
Neighbors briefs
Rockers launch tour to support Democrats
Abortion pill law in court
Public safety briefs
Assistant principal hired for Shawnee
Firemen hit with BB shots
Interim SCLC leader to stay
Bad wigs, bad togs, good cause
Road opponents pin hopes on park
Study: Air to be dirtier in 50 years

ENQUIRER COLUMNISTS
Bronson: Council's back, so is stupidity See a pattern?
Kenton Democrats to honor Hollis at picnic, hear Clooney
Tragedy brings 5 grandchildren into their home

LIVES REMEMBERED
Donald Flemer fought religious, racial bias
Rev. James Sutton was foster parent to 148 children

KENTUCKY STORIES
Church trial date delayed
Financial records ordered held
Stumbo's office offers to share report
Kentucky lags in providing homes for mentally disabled
Westwood campaign dismisses 'stunt'