Tuesday, August 24, 2004
Boos echo: Silly sport, poor calls
But Bhardwaj poised, diplomatic
ATHENS - A half hour before 15,000 people filled the gymnastics hall with the boos of a Philadelphia crowd at a pro wrestling tag-team, Mohini Bhardwaj lost a protest that likely cost her a bronze medal.
Let's be precise. Let's be as perfect as a pointed toe. Let us, in other words, do better than the people who judge this silly sport. After Bhardwaj competed in the floor exercise, her coach Chris Waller approached the start value judges and said wait a minute.
A start value is a degree of difficulty. A guy walking a high wire between tall buildings would have a higher start value than a guy walking in a field of clover. Waller argued that Bhardwaj's value was 9.9, not the 9.7 the judges assessed.
Still with me?
This was because Waller claimed Bhardwaj did complete a move that made the 9.9 value obvious. She didn't do the move well, but she did do it. The judges claimed she did not. Without the move, her start value decreased.
![[img]](bhardwaj.jpg)
Mohini Bhardwaj looks up at her score.
(AP photo)
|
Bhardwaj's take was this: "It was a leap connection after my second pass. If you don't get it all the way around, you don't get a bonus for it. I guess the judges didn't catch it."
At Waller's request, the start value judges viewed a replay. They said no dice. Bottom line: Had Bhardwaj been given the 9.9 value, she might have won the bronze medal (Spain's Patricia Moreno was third with 9.487). Instead, she finished sixth at 9.312.
As befits her sport and her age (25), Bhardwaj was remarkably poised about the whole thing. Some of us would be doing flying quadruple Yurchenkos off the ceiling.
"If you've seen any of the event finals, you'll kind of understand this is the way the sport is," she said. "It's a shame."
That's a nice way to put it. After what occurred here Monday, it's over-the-top nice. When Bhardwaj stops doing advanced tumbling and flipping, she should consider a career in politics.
A gymnastics meet isn't supposed to sound like a bad call on 4th-and-1 in December. This one did. Earlier in the day, a Romanian male gym-guy was awarded an impossible-to-get score on the first of two vaults. It was enough to give him a bronze medal. The judge charged with making sure the scoring was accurate was Romanian.
Imagine that.
At night, the crowd had seen enough. After the Russian Alexei Nemov scored what the fans felt was a criminally low number on the horizontal bar, they erupted. The crowd booed for 10 solid minutes, until Nemov himself urged them with his arms to cease and desist.
And we will say it here and now: Greek gymnastics fans are beautiful people.
So loud and persistent were they, the judges actually increased Nemov's score. Imagine the refs at an NFL game giving the home team a free TD after the fans went nuts on a pass interference call.
"I would like to thank all those people for doing what they did tonight," Nemov said. "You cannot fool the fans."
You can fool the judges, however. Bhardwaj did a move they said she didn't, and lost a chance at a bronze medal. "The sport is based on what you see at a given time. Humans are judging it, so there is human error. Not everybody sees the same thing. So it's not always the same. So that's the way it is," she said.
Bhardwaj said she'll take from the Olympics a simple lesson: "Hard work at pursuing specific goals pays off at the end."
Spoken like a person who won't let judges spoil a good time.
The problem with gymnastics, one of them anyway, is that humans seeking perfection are judged by other humans whose eyesight and biases make perfection eternally impossible.
Such a beautiful sport to be so screwed up.
---
E-mail pdaugherty@enquirer.com
OLYMPICS
Daugherty: USA softball team gives coach courage
Boos echo: Silly sport, poor calls
Teen's overtime goal keeps hopes alive
Wariner leads U.S. 400 sweep
Olympics special section
Olympics photo gallery, multimedia
BENGALS / NFL
Bengals cut punter, quarterback
Meet the Bengals: Patrick Johnson
Lewis: Warrick right on schedule
Chiefs 24, Rams 7
Ogunleye unfazed by big Bears contract
Rivers ends holdout, signs with SD
COLLEGE FOOTBALL
UC transfer in mix to be kicker
Miami confident in Betts at QB
HIGH SCHOOL FOOTBALL
CovCath vaults to No. 2 in prep poll
Pick the winners
High school sports results, schedules
COLLEGE HOOPS
Everhart pulls out of running for UC job
REDS / BASEBALL
Going good? Yes and no
Reds vs. Cardinals series preview
Wrigley repairs pass inspection
NL: Clemens notches his 323rd victory
AL: Lilly strikes out 13, ends Red Sox streak
AAA: Columbus 6, Louisville 3
MORE SPORTS HEADLINES
Sports digest
Sports today on TV, radio
THIS WEEK'S SPORTS POLL
Which college football team will have the best record this season?