By Bruce Schreiner
The Associated Press
LOUISVILLE - The Kentucky Court of Appeals on Friday dismissed an advocacy group's motion to block the state from resupplying Gov. Ernie Fletcher's spending plan with taxpayer money.
A three-judge panel ruled that the group Common Cause had sought a restraining order, which the judges said is not appealable.
Common Cause has challenged Fletcher's authority to run state government without a budget. The citizens group claims the Kentucky Constitution forbids Fletcher to spend unappropriated state money.
The General Assembly failed to pass a budget before adjourning on April 13. Kentucky began a new fiscal year July 1 without a budget. In its place, Fletcher issued a 90-day "public services continuation plan."
Common Cause's motion sought a court order blocking state Treasurer Jonathan Miller from releasing unappropriated funds after Sept. 30.
Franklin County Circuit Judge Roger Crittenden ruled against Common Cause, which then took its case to the appellate court.
Richard Beliles, Common Cause state chairman, had told the appeals court that the motion was intended to put "judicial pressure" on Fletcher and the legislature to pass a budget.
Common Cause contended that what it requested from the trial judge was a temporary injunction, which the appeals court can review.
The group's motion contained a reference to a restraining order, the appeals court said. The trial court, in its order, referred to a restraining order, the panel said.
"Its denial of the motion, in substance as well as in form, was the denial of a restraining order, not an injunction," said Judge William L. Knopf of Louisville, who wrote for the panel.
"If this was not a result Common Cause expected, the burden was on it to seek clarification from the trial court."
Judges R.W. Dyche III of London and Rick A. Johnson of Mayfield joined in the opinion.
Beliles said Friday he would refile his motion in the circuit court. His new motion will clearly request a temporary injunction, he said.
Beliles said he lost the initial rounds on a procedural matter without the appeals court taking up the merits of his case.
"This is not the end," he said in a telephone interview. "I'm definitely going to go ahead and correct the procedural problem."
Fletcher's attorney, Sheryl Snyder, said he was pleased but not surprised by the ruling.
"So far, the position that the governor has taken has been vindicated by the courts at every turn," Snyder said.
BIG WEEKEND
Let's get this party started
Successful Classic striving for more
Best places to eat
What's new downtown, on riverfront
Big events fill the weekend
Downtown event map (PDF)
More Big Weekend coverage
MIKE ALLEN SCANDAL
Allen's lawyers given week to derail lawsuit
Collins moves to new job
Lobbyist fined in stockbroker investigation
Special section: Mike Allen coverage
TOP LOCAL HEADLINES
Complaint is No. 3 for judge
West Side talks sewers
Share indigent funds, TriHealth urges
Bus hits two vehicles, sending 3 to hospital
BMX, skateboarders shoot for gold
Lebanon couple charged after OxyContin theft
Family groups lash out at P&G
Voinovich begins re-election tour
Drug imports law draws blank
Cincinnati policeman charged with assault
Local news briefs
KENTUCKY HEADLINES
Meadow Glen can be built
Actor arrested; lobsters OK
Hispanic students to benefit from gala
10-year-old bike rider struck by car
Mountain region drenched by remnants of Hurricane Ivan
Bunning proposes single debate with Mongiardo
Appeals court rules against Common Cause in budget case
EDUCATION
$10M Miami U. gift honors son
Childhood education key, funds a problem
Pay-to-participate begins
Teacher buyouts offered
NKU gives lower tuition rate to some Indiana residents
KEA board considers strike proposal
Lakota East students collect goodies for troops
NEIGHBORS
'Topless' sign leads to court case
Pastor a 'good fit' for Pleasant Ridge parish
Jordan's Queen Noor to speak at Miami U
W. Chester police in their new building
ENQUIRER COLUMNS
Visitor will discuss HIV and Africa
Fifth Third CEO, helpers care
LIVES REMEMBERED
W. Clermont treasurer was well respected
Odean 'Sis' Poindexter, hospital nurse