By Linda A. Johnson
The Associated Press
TRENTON, N.J. - Which is more harmful to your health - a smoky bar or a city street filled with diesel truck fumes? Well, you might want to skip your next happy hour.
Smoky bars and casinos have up to 50 times more cancer-causing particles in the air than highways and city streets clogged with diesel trucks at rush hour, according to a study that also shows indoor air pollution virtually disappears once smoking is banned.
Conducted by the researcher who first showed secondhand smoke causes thousands of U.S. lung cancer deaths each year, the study found casino and bar workers are exposed to particulate pollution at far greater levels than the government allows outdoors.
"This paper will help localities pass smoking bans," predicted the author, James Repace, a biophysicist who works as a secondhand-smoke consultant after spending 30 years as a federal researcher. "It shows how beneficial smoking bans are for hospitality workers and patrons."
Repace tested air in a casino, a pool hall and six taverns in Delaware in November 2002 and in January 2003, two months after the state imposed a strict indoor smoking ban.
His detectors measured two substances blamed for tobacco-related cancers: a group of chemicals called particulate polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, or PPAHs, and respirable particles - airborne soot small enough to penetrate the lungs.
"They are the most dangerous" substances in secondhand smoke, said Repace, a visiting assistant clinical professor at Tufts University School of Medicine in Boston.
Repace said his research also showed that ventilation systems - sometimes touted by tavern, restaurant and casino groups as an alternative to smoking bans - cannot exchange air fast enough to keep up with the smoke.
The study, published in the September issue of the Journal of Occupational and Environmental Medicine, was partly funded by the nation's largest philanthropic organization devoted to health care, the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation of Plainsboro, N.J.
ELECTION 2004
Edwards puts emphasis on plan to create jobs
Cheney says Bush election crucial to win terror war
Bush campaign raises $260 million, doubling previous contribution record
Election 2004 page
TOP LOCAL HEADLINES
Summer's air cool, healthy
Development post to be filled within weeks
Forensic science helps trace threatening letter
Driver involved in fatal crash released from jail after 7 days
3 hit by gunshots fired at crowd
Court allows petitions for ban
State asked to fund work on I-75 section near I-74
State probe of judge sought
Man who ordered mistaken-identity killing gets 5 years
CBS apologizes for Bush military report
Review board sustains six allegations
Xavier students, teenagers scuffle
Study: Air worse in bars than in traffic
Politics, budget needs will drive debate on temporary sales tax increase
Local news briefs
KENTUCKY HEADLINES
Statewide poll finds Bunning well in lead
Cities, businesses watch river level
Deputy details case vs. ex-con
Shopping center fills
Jury selection begins in trial of former officer charged with murder
Man who shot bear gets fine, no jail time
Kentucky news briefs
EDUCATION
Traffic ties expected as UC opens Wednesday
Reading cuts school sports
Some N.Ky. school districts likely to close for protest
Fletcher tells teachers to change insurance plans
Madeira teachers vote against joining union
NEIGHBORS
More elderly, more services required
Monroe to annex 43 acres for Kroger
Clough Pike closure to last 2 more weeks
ENQUIRER COLUMNS
Bronson: P&G boycott keeps issue in spotlight
Library offers photo contest
LIVES REMEMBERED
Alexander Roy, 90, missionary and area pastor