By Karen Gutierrez
Enquirer staff writer
Two Northern Kentucky school districts are using a computer service to scan student writing and offer automated criticism.
The idea: To save English teachers from burnout, especially at the fourth-, seventh-and 12th-grade levels.
"I think it's wonderful," said Gene Kirchner, deputy superintendent of the Walton-Verona school system. "This is the type of technology the world now presents to us. If you're not going to use it, why have it?"
The service is called Criterion. It's sold by Educational Testing Service, the same company that administers the SAT.
Criterion uses automated scoring technology to provide students with feedback on grammar, usage, spelling and style. Students log onto the service through the Internet.
This year, the Fort Thomas and Walton-Verona school districts each will spend about $4,000 to purchase access for students. They are the only districts in Northern Kentucky using it.
It should be especially helpful in the fourth, seventh and 12th grades, Kirchner said.
That's when Kentucky students must choose five examples of their best writing and collect them in portfolios. The portfolios are then scored and used to judge school performance under the state's accountability system.
It's a pressure cooker for teachers. Many spend nights, weekends and holidays reading rough drafts of essays.
Teachers are not allowed to directly point out errors, because the writing is supposed to be the students' own work. So teachers write vague notes suggesting areas that could be improved, or they "conference" with students to discuss issues in their writing.
It's so time-consuming that Amy Cody, a seventh-grade teacher at Walton-Verona High School, almost took a leave of absence last year so she could pay more attention to her family. "I used to read them and read them and read them, and I about drove myself crazy," Cody said of portfolio pieces.
Criterion should help because it will address basics such as sentence length, subject-verb agreement and overuse of the pronoun "I."
The program indicates such problems and refers students to an online handbook for more information
Before purchasing the service, the districts checked with the Kentucky Department of Education to make sure it wouldn't violate ethics rules.
A state official observed Criterion in the Fort Thomas school system and pronounced it acceptable, Assistant Superintendent John Williamson said.
The program is "probably one step up from Microsoft Word," he said.
Especially in advanced high school classes, the feedback is too generic to be of much use, Williamson said.
Still, Criterion does help teachers juggle classroom duties. While they work one-on-one with some students, others can be running their papers through the service, Williamson said.
TOP LOCAL HEADLINES
Staff describes judge as bully, intimidating
Collectors on the cutting edge
Only at-risk to get flu shots at first
Flu-shot shortage vexes U.S. hospitals, officials
Q&A: Who needs flu shot, who can skip them
Miami U. rape suspect indicted
Prosecutor's office lambasted
Tall Stacks deficit vanishes
Elections board director fears trouble
Oops! Cheney had met Edwards
Election 2004 section
United Jewish Cemetery struck again by vandals
Mason High student arrested at his home
Mayor's group invites Luken to join for talks
Weather Service reviewing flood forecast complaints
Gay-marriage measure splits senators, bishops
Union council opposes city tax repeal
Local news briefs
Group aims at civic literacy
Davis copied GOP answers
Team owners get case delay
Jam sessions a staple
House panel begins hearings
When volcano erupts, he's in his element
Regents to urge cap on tuition
Writing tips online for 2 N.Ky. schools
Committee recommends in-school GED program
Princeton wins honors for its video projects
School site to be cleaned of lead
Deerfield Twp. looks for cash to clean up lead
Mason wants voter OK on its 'S corporation' tax
Mt. Healthy to explain tax
Symmes Twp. trustees OK using park land for road
Community center costs worry trustees
'Horseburger' ads' true purpose revealed
Bronson: Theft, litter, closed toilets; still they stay
Crowley: Davis, Clooney to face off
Howard: Kids reach out to Ivan's victims
Edwin Barth, oldest farmer
Joseph Hiestand, former state rep