Thursday, October 14, 2004

Council rejects police plans


Training, task force ideas defeated

By Kevin Aldridge
Enquirer staff writer

DOWNTOWN - More than 100 people from Price Hill and Westwood packed Cincinnati City Council's chambers Wednesday in hopes that city leaders would reaffirm their commitment to fighting crime and adding more police officers.

Instead, they watched council members bicker, and in the end, reject three crime-fighting proposals.

The first to go down - by a 5-4 vote - was Councilman John Cranley's motion that would have guaranteed two police recruit classes in the next two-year budget. Cranley argued that with an attrition rate of nearly 60 officers a year, the city needed to have two classes to reach and maintain its goal of 1,075 officers.

City administrators delayed a fall police recruit class until December because of the city's budget woes. Cranley said he wanted to ensure council would not use similar money-saving tactics in the future.

"This vote says that if we have to make tough decisions, this is not the top priority," Cranley said. "It's sad that after 58 homicides (this year), this is not our priority."

Vice Mayor Alicia Reece's motions to establish a homicide task force and an anti-gang unit also failed. Reece had proposed creating centralized police teams that would focus strictly on the issue of gangs and homicides - similar to what the city had done with the Violent Crimes Task Force in 2001.

Both motions were resoundingly defeated 7-2.

"I am disappointed," said Reece, who voted against Cranley's motion. "If you don't like the plan I've presented, I've asked for an alternative plan. I haven't seen it."

Some council members who opposed Cranley's motion said they did so because they didn't want to tie the hands of city administrators should the city's budget problems get worse. Others said they felt Cranley's motion repeated the commitment council made in its policy budget and directives to the city administration approved in June.

"If it's true that they already voted for it, why can't we vote for it again?" Cranley said. "They didn't vote for it because it would have committed this council to saying that we definitely wanted this."

Many residents left the meeting disappointed that politics and rhetoric appeared to have won the day. During the public speaking session, dozens of residents pleaded with council members for more police and a plan to combat crime in their neighborhoods.

Janice Ludwig, of Westwood, said: "Why would someone vote against anything to prevent crime? I don't get that."

E-mail kaldridge@enquirer.com




TOP STORIES
Bishop Woods in peril?
Seton High School details expansion plan
Officer graduates, loses job
County settles on stadium

PRESIDENTIAL DEBATE
Gay-rights sides target black vote
Bush, Kerry spar on domestic issues
Noonan: Kerry 'worst of party'
Kerry's plan, Bush's past declarations scrutinized
Xavier students gather, let own voices be heard
Transcript of Bush, Kerry debate

ELECTION 2004
Taft: 'No' on same-sex issue
Insults fly in Senate race
Vote monitor optimistic
Lawyers rate candidates
Westwood and Groob square off tonight
Lawyer sues over lost form to vote
Middletown streets on ballot
Election 2004 page

IN THE TRISTATE
EPA, trash firm debate leak from closed landfill
Council rejects police plans
Fire union disputes cost-saving plan
Museum faces cutbacks
Frist: Doctors leaving Ohio
Two teenagers arrested in Royal Crown hotel fire
Witness: Mom not hysterical, though fire trapped her infant
Local news briefs
Mayor of Madeira retires, is moving to Warren County
Man ruled insane in murder of activist
Milford police chief resigns, halting property misuse case
State audit faults Morrow
Neighbors briefs
Killer who blamed his victim is executed at Lucasville prison
Public safety briefs
Northwest Local Schools loses board president
Sierra Club pushes renewable energy
New drivers get look at real-life tragedies
OT for Bush rally covered

THEATER REVIEWS
'Thirty Ghosts' uneven
Dancers make impact

ENQUIRER COLUMNISTS
Bronson: Council deaf to pleas for crime control
Good Things Happening

LIVES REMEMBERED
Alex C. Papas, 84, made candy

KENTUCKY STORIES
Towne Center should proceed with latest OK
River view the draw for condos
Losing weight inspired teacher to help others
State insurance plan outlined
N. Ky. news briefs
Dad, lawyer run from SUV after custody case; mom held
Most N.Ky. schools meeting state goals
House fire victim loses Fla. home, too
Fletcher blamed for flap