Saturday, October 30, 2004
Mike Allen investigation nears end with questioning of Collins
By Sharon Coolidge
Enquirer staff writer
For more than six hours Friday, an investigator for the Ohio Attorney General's Office questioned the woman who accused her boss, Hamilton County Prosecutor Mike Allen, of sexual harassment.
The interview is one of the last pieces of Attorney General Jim Petro's investigation into the sexual harassment complaint lodged by Assistant Hamilton County Prosecutor Rebecca Collins against Allen and the way the prosecutor's office handled the complaint.
Before the investigator began asking questions, Collins, 33, read from a written statement, that was also provided to a reporter. In the statement, she said she never sought a relationship with Allen and likened their relationship to that of an abusive husband and battered wife.
"I believe that our relationship between December 1999 and August 2003 was 'consensual' only in the sense that a woman's relationship with an abusive husband can be called 'consensual.'
"I enjoyed some good times with Mike Allen," she added. "However, I now understand that our relationship began and continued because of the power and influence of Mr. Allen and his control over my job and career."
Allen, 48, has admitted to having a 31/2-year extramarital affair with Collins, but has insisted it was consensual. His attorney, Michael Hawkins, has called Collins' complaint "outrageous and false."
Hawkins could not be reached for comment Friday night.
Collins' attorneys sat at her side during the interview Friday.
Petro has said the investigation will focus on sexual-harassment claims that Collins made against Allen in August in an internal complaint and, two weeks later, in Collins' federal lawsuit. The suit also names Hamilton County Commissioners as defendants. The lawsuit seeks unspecified damages, lost pay and benefits and that she be granted promotions she claims she was denied.
The state investigation came at the request of the prosecutor's office.
Allen has already spoken with investigators.
"We are very concerned about how the investigation was conducted," said one of Collins' three attorneys, Randy Freking. "It was so unusual because they interviewed everyone they think is a witness before Rebecca."
Collins should have been the first witness, Freking said. That way, he said, others interviewed would be able to corroborate or dispute her version of events.
Freking said he is also concerned that the investigator did not ask questions about how Allen handled a letter written to him by one of Collins' lawyers that included a draft of the lawsuit. Nor did the investigator ask questions about the internal sexual-harassment complaint, he said.
Freking expects the results of the investigation to be released in a few weeks.
The investigator who questioned Collins declined to comment on the investigation.
The attorney general's investigation began Sept. 14 and was expected to last four to six weeks. The results of the investigation will be made public, Petro has promised.
E-mail scoolidge@enquirer.com
ELECTION 2004
It may be trick, not treat, for Bush
Drowning in TV political ads?
Election protests thwarted
10 states that could swing it
Clermont district makes third try
Clermont County challenger derides 'club' atmosphere
What's in a name? Most often, victory
Campaign watchers complain
Budget key in 30th District
Union activist big underdog
Scandal tinges judge race
Schools say new levies are crucial
Northeastern faces deficit
Edgewood and Franklin schools put taxes to vote
Election turnout could be at 70%
'Limp wrist' charge angers Mongiardo
Fletcher name chafes brother
Facts to help Kentucky voters with Tuesday's election
Nader's name is on the ballot, but you can't cast vote for him
Bush, Kerry adopt softer tone in final days
Election 2004 section
TOP LOCAL HEADLINES
Mike Allen investigation nears end with questioning of Collins
Accord to limit fire cuts
Luken: Cuts get city back to basics
Captive's family recounts ordeal
Second trial brings 55-year sentence
St. Joseph adds space to handle growth
Local news briefs
KENTUCKY HEADLINES
Wreck spurs two probes
Bracken Co. pit bull owners go to court
Smoking ban splits voters
2 teens OK after crash in Independence
Ky. gets more flu vaccine via feds
EDUCATION
Teens' political involvement starts as class assignment
Cincinnati teachers' union hires people to call voters
Money needed to save clinic
Wilson, McKinley alumni offered brick mementos
NEIGHBORS
Adults go all-out for ghostly good time
The rush lingers, long after the fright
Elmwood playground assembled with love
Gorman Farm needs hands
United Way lawsuit settled in Warren Co.
LIVES REMEMBERED
Margaret Rehring ran libraries in city schools
Frank Catanzaro built produce giant from $13
ENQUIRER COLUMNS
Crowley: Serious office politics
Toys for Tots kicks off Sunday
Notes found describing HUC founding