By Janice Morse
Enquirer staff writer
HAMILTON - The crash that killed a Butler County couple has led to charges against a Harrison man in a case that shows how inaccurate preliminary information - and witness statements - can be, police said Tuesday.
Contrary to previously published reports, David Brinkman, 51, of Morgan Township, was not at fault in the Oct. 23 three-vehicle crash that killed him and his wife and hurt two other motorists, said Butler County Sheriff's Capt. G. Michael Grimes.
The positions of the vehicles, damage on the vehicles and patterns of scattered debris helped traffic-crash reconstructionists determine that Benjamin B. Holbert, 21, of Harrison, caused the crash by running a stop sign at Ohio 748 and Layhigh Road in Ross Township, Grimes said.
Initial witness statements "didn't quite jibe" with the physical evidence, Grimes said, noting that "preliminary investigations are just that - preliminary." Also, he said, witness perceptions may be influenced by other witnesses' statements and by the traumatic experience of seeing a fatal crash.
The incident shows the need for people not to jump to conclusions before investigators thoroughly complete their tasks, Grimes said.
Holbert is charged with two counts of vehicular homicide and a stop-sign violation. Vehicular homicide is a first-degree misdemeanor carrying a fine of up to $1,000 and a jail sentence of up to six months.
Holbert told police he had made a wrong turn, was in unfamiliar territory and, because of heavy rain, didn't see the stop sign as his 2000 Dodge Dakota pickup traveled southeast on Layhigh around 7:45 p.m. that Saturday, Grimes said.
Brinkman was driving a 2004 Chevrolet Aveo compact northeast on Ohio 748. Brinkman had the right of way when the Dodge went through the Layhigh stop sign and struck the driver's side of the Aveo, Grimes said. The Aveo slid into a utility pole and the Dodge hit a 1997 Pontiac Grand Am. That car's driver, Debra Cole, 42, was treated at the scene. Holbert was taken to Fort Hamilton Hospital.
Cole and Holbert both were wearing lap and shoulder belts.
But Brinkman and his wife, Sherry, 50, were unbelted, a crash report says. Sherry Brinkman was thrown from the wreckage. If she had been belted, she might have survived, Grimes said. Both died at the scene.
The Brinkmans, who had been married 26 years, left a grown son, Keith, and a foster son, Robert Robinson, among other survivors.
David Brinkman was a champion weightlifter with the U.S. Olympic Weightlifting Federation and worked as a steamfitter and maintenance supervisor at Seagram's Distillery.
Sherry Brinkman worked in the Miami University personnel department and was a Sunday school teacher at the church.
OHIO ELECTION RESULTS:
Ohio provisional ballots may decide presidential election
Voters repeal amendment on gay rights
Ohio Supreme Court: GOP's justices appear to be buttressing majority
Voinovich has no trouble winning 2nd Senate term
Sycamore levy passes; four others fail
Kerry effort falls short in Ohio
Ohio Republicans aim to maintain grip in House, Senate
Ohio election briefs
Ohio Issue 1 passes
Turnout heavy in suburbs
MU students hit the polls
HAMILTON CO. RACES
Cincinnati school levy passes
Hospital tax leading despite opposition
CLERMONT CO. RACES
Clermont County: Republicans remain choice in early count
Clermont County tax issues: Long lines delay counting
BUTLER CO. RACES
Fairfield levy passes
Butler commission: All incumbents being returned
Butler levies: Support strong for health, social care funding
Butler County Sheriff: Jones likely successor to Gabbard
WARREN CO. RACES
Heavy turnout, long lines delay vote count
Kings levy passes by slim margin
Indiana governor: Daniels prevails after tough, costly slugfest
Ballot misprint may affect Ind. school board race
KENTUCKY ELECTION RESULTS:
Alexandria: Voters stick with City Council's six incumbents
Bellevue City Council: Two incumbents losing seats with 4 of 5 precincts counted
Covington: Sanders and Stricker joining City Commission
Campbell County: Ward holds on to retain seat on Circuit Court
Florence City Council: One newcomer, five incumbents win seats
Independence: Four who opposed insurance tax win
Newport: Mayor, all four on council will be keeping their seats
Suburban schools: Campbell, other area boards get fresh faces
Villa Hills, Taylor Mill: Taxes to fix, replace city streets rejected
Urban schools: Newcomer ousts incumbent, snags Newport board seat
N. Ky. election briefs
Popular president dominates Kentucky
Ky. Senate: Bunning wins - but race was close
Ky. House: This time around, Davis prevails
Issue One: Kentucky overwhelmingly says yes to no-gay-marriage
State's determined voters brave long lines, waits, rain
23rd Senate District: Westwood survives challenge by Groob
Ex-Gov. Carroll wins Frankfort seat
State Senate: Republican Thayer wins a full term in new seat
67th House District: Keene's win preserves spot for Democrats
IN THE TRISTATE
Shelter director traveled from needing to helping
Help Habitat by hiring yard rakers
Father inspired mission journey
Cone throw may bring legal action
Police dogs could get TV time at competition
Harrison man charged in auto fatals
Exhibit to spotlight 350 years of Judaism in America
Medal of Honor graves get special markers
Local news briefs
Neighbors news briefs
Good Things Happening
Gay Weber designed jet engines for GE
Time of change in Crestview Hills
Waltz or swing, timid students learn to let go
Florence Freedom has a deal
$545,000 grant to bolster Ky. health-care work force
N. Ky. news briefs
Jewelry gone after autopsy of corpse
N.Ky. schools' education guide available online
Murder counts filed in wreck that killed 2