Wednesday, November 3, 2004

Ky. Senate: Bunning wins - but race was close


Gaffes increased Mongiardo threat

By Bruce Schreiner
The Associated Press

HEBRON - Republican Sen. Jim Bunning held off a strong challenge by Democrat Daniel Mongiardo on Tuesday to win a second term, scoring a razor-thin victory following a campaign in which the candidates exchanged increasingly sharp personal attacks.

With all but four precincts reporting statewide, Bunning led Mongiardo by only about 18,000 votes out of more than 1.7 million cast.

Bunning, 73, a Hall of Fame major-league pitcher from Southgate, once was viewed as a lock to win re-election, but saw his edge slip away in the campaign's closing days.

"How sweet it is," Bunning said during his victory speech at the Airport Marriott hotel in Boone County.

"I want to thank everyone here this evening," Bunning told the cheering crowd. "Everyone, for their votes and their support."

Republicans had an anxious time watching results as Mongiardo dashed to an early lead that lingered well into the evening.

"There's no doubt in my mind that Jim Bunning is a strong closer," said Marc Wilson, a GOP strategist. "And he closed one for the GOP in Kentucky Tuesday night."

Bunning used a strong performance in Northern Kentucky and in rural Republican strongholds to overcome Mongiardo's lopsided advantage in Louisville and Lexington.

Bunning stressed his experience, his conservatism and support of President Bush.

Those factors were too much for Mongiardo to overcome.

The incumbent, who previously served in Congress and the Kentucky statehouse, called this his toughest race ever and thanked his supporters for their "vote of confidence."

"I'm humbled by the honor of your support and give you my solemn promise that I will work every single day and give everything I have to be the best U.S. senator that can represent you," Bunning said.

With 99 percent of the precincts reporting, Bunning had 861,424 votes, or 51 percent, and Mongiardo had 843,011 votes, or 49 percent.

"Bunning owes a great deal to President Bush's margin in Kentucky and the help of senior Sen. Mitch McConnell," said Larry Sabato, director of the Center for Politics at the University of Virginia. "Otherwise, he might well have been defeated."

Bush carried Kentucky easily Tuesday, and Bunning appeared with the president at a rally at Great American Ball Park in Cincinnati on Sunday. Bunning wielded an edge in name recognition and campaign cash, but the Hall of Fame pitcher was put on the defensive by missteps that boosted Mongiardo, who began the race as a little-known state senator from Appalachia.

"Only in America can a kid with a funny last name from the mountains of Appalachia get a chance to do what I've been able to do in the past year," Mongiardo said Tuesday night.

Mongiardo, a doctor from the mountain town of Hazard, had a double-digit deficit in a poll in September until he gained momentum thanks to Bunning's foibles. National Democrats, sensing a chance to pick up a seat, poured more than $1 million into Mongiardo's campaign in the closing weeks.

Mongiardo branded his first-term opponent as ineffective. The Democrat also repeated his populist-tinged promises to help families strapped by high costs for health care, prescription drugs and college tuition.

"Jim Bunning can't talk about those issues because he doesn't understand those issues," Mongiardo said. "He's been out of touch with the people of Kentucky."

Bunning's big advantages in name recognition and campaign cash were offset by a series of gaffes and missteps that eroded his once-commanding lead in the polls and put Mongiardo within striking distance.

Bunning once compared Mongiardo's appearance to one of Saddam Hussein's sons. Then he made an unsubstantiated claim that opposition staffers beat his wife "black and blue" at a political picnic.

Bunning acknowledged that he hasn't run a perfect campaign but declined to elaborate.

"The only time I've ever been perfect was for about two hours in 1964," Bunning, a baseball Hall of Famer, said Monday in a reference to a perfect game he pitched for the Philadelphia Phillies.

The race got ugly late, with Bunning and his supporters accusing Mongiardo and his campaign team of spreading untrue rumors that the senator was in poor health and possibly suffering from dementia.

Mongiardo denied having anything to do with the rumors.

But then, on a weeklong bus trip last week, Bunning's supporters insinuated repeatedly that Mongiardo was gay by calling him a "limp wrist" and a "switch-hitter."

Republicans insisted the terms were not references to sexual orientation. Bunning did not use the terms, but he also refused to repudiate the comments.

Enquirer reporter Patrick Crowley contributed.




OHIO ELECTION RESULTS:
Ohio provisional ballots may decide presidential election
Voters repeal amendment on gay rights
Ohio Supreme Court: GOP's justices appear to be buttressing majority
Voinovich has no trouble winning 2nd Senate term
Sycamore levy passes; four others fail
Kerry effort falls short in Ohio
Ohio Republicans aim to maintain grip in House, Senate
Ohio election briefs
Ohio Issue 1 passes
Turnout heavy in suburbs
MU students hit the polls
HAMILTON CO. RACES
Cincinnati school levy passes
Hospital tax leading despite opposition
CLERMONT CO. RACES
Clermont County: Republicans remain choice in early count
Clermont County tax issues: Long lines delay counting
BUTLER CO. RACES
Fairfield levy passes
Butler commission: All incumbents being returned
Butler levies: Support strong for health, social care funding
Butler County Sheriff: Jones likely successor to Gabbard
WARREN CO. RACES
Heavy turnout, long lines delay vote count
Kings levy passes by slim margin
INDIANA RACES
Indiana governor: Daniels prevails after tough, costly slugfest
Ballot misprint may affect Ind. school board race

KENTUCKY ELECTION RESULTS:
LOCAL RACES
Alexandria: Voters stick with City Council's six incumbents
Bellevue City Council: Two incumbents losing seats with 4 of 5 precincts counted
Covington: Sanders and Stricker joining City Commission
Campbell County: Ward holds on to retain seat on Circuit Court
Florence City Council: One newcomer, five incumbents win seats
Independence: Four who opposed insurance tax win
Newport: Mayor, all four on council will be keeping their seats
Suburban schools: Campbell, other area boards get fresh faces
Villa Hills, Taylor Mill: Taxes to fix, replace city streets rejected
Urban schools: Newcomer ousts incumbent, snags Newport board seat
N. Ky. election briefs
STATE RACES
Popular president dominates Kentucky
Ky. Senate: Bunning wins - but race was close
Ky. House: This time around, Davis prevails
Issue One: Kentucky overwhelmingly says yes to no-gay-marriage
State's determined voters brave long lines, waits, rain
23rd Senate District: Westwood survives challenge by Groob
Ex-Gov. Carroll wins Frankfort seat
State Senate: Republican Thayer wins a full term in new seat
67th House District: Keene's win preserves spot for Democrats

IN THE TRISTATE
Shelter director traveled from needing to helping
Help Habitat by hiring yard rakers
Father inspired mission journey
Cone throw may bring legal action
Police dogs could get TV time at competition
Harrison man charged in auto fatals
Exhibit to spotlight 350 years of Judaism in America
Medal of Honor graves get special markers
Local news briefs
Neighbors news briefs

ENQUIRER COLUMNISTS
Good Things Happening

LIVES REMEMBERED
Gay Weber designed jet engines for GE

KENTUCKY STORIES
Time of change in Crestview Hills
Waltz or swing, timid students learn to let go
Florence Freedom has a deal
$545,000 grant to bolster Ky. health-care work force
N. Ky. news briefs
Jewelry gone after autopsy of corpse
N.Ky. schools' education guide available online
Murder counts filed in wreck that killed 2